| Term | Most Illustrious Companion | Past Illustrious Master of |
|---|---|---|
| 2023 | D.W. Winchester | Valley Council |
| 2022 | Hans C. "Sky" Olsen | Hiram Council |
| 2021 | Jeffrey D. Johnson | Hiram Council |
| 2020 | Jeffrey D. Johnson | Hiram Council |
| 2019 | Christopher A. Larsen II | Hiram Council |
| 2018 | Stephen A. Balke | Santa Fe Council |
| 2017 | Casper J. Brown | Valley Council |
| 2016 | *Raymond D. MacDonald | Organ Council |
| 2015 | Paul A. Brehm | Hiram Council |
| 2014 | Fred E. Kellogg | Hiram Council |
| 2013 | Mark Z. Oldknow | Santa Fe Council |
| 2012 | Dion A. Newhouse | Santa Fe Council |
| 2011 | Gerard K. Pulz | Valley Council |
| 2010 | Richard G. Browne | Navajo Council |
| 2009 | *Hendrick C. de Bruin | Zuni Council |
| 2008 | Arland M. Blackburn | Organ Council |
| 2007 | *Robert E. Noble (Hon) | Valley Council |
| 2007 | Dennis R. Detrow | Hiram Council |
| 2006 | Robert J. Keene | Zuni Council |
| 2005 | Dennis P. Herman | Navajo Council |
| 2004 | **Antonio E. Astorga | Santa Fe Council |
| 2003 | *Dickerson R. Watkins | Hiram Council |
| 2002 | Larry J. Brownfield | Hiram Council |
| 2001 | *Jesse O. Martindale | Navajo Council |
| 2000 | *Kermit K. Schauer | Organ Council |
| Term | Most Illustrious Companion | Past Illustrious Master of |
