| Term | Most Illustrious Companion | Past Illustrious Master of |
|---|---|---|
| 1974 | *Harlan H. Morris | Jemez* Council |
| 1973 | *Charles A. L. Fletcher | Hiram Council |
| 1972 | *Lynn D. Hudgeons | Zuni Council |
| 1971 | *Clifford R. Morrison | Hiram Council |
| 1970 | *Fred C. Piper | Navajo Council |
| 1969 | *Fred E. Hunt | Valley Council |
| 1968 | *Marvin J. Baker | Hiram Council |
| 1967 | *Phillip Witherspoon | Organ Council |
| 1966 | *Ed Hein | Hiram Council |
| 1965 | *Albert Hudson | Valley Council |
| 1964 | *J. Leo Evett | Hiram Council |
| 1964 | *Henry B. Coddington | Zuni Council |
| 1963 | *Wilhelm A. Wunsch | Organ Council |
| 1962 | *Vincent W. Bowman | Hiram Council |
| 1961 | *Michael E. Croteau | Organ Council |
| 1960 | *Frederick W. Blocksom | Valley Council |
| 1959 | *Herbert C. Denny | Zuni Council |
| 1958 | *J. Carter Goodloe | Organ Council |
| 1957 | *Julius J. Richter | Hiram Council |
| 1956 | *John C. Kost, Jr. | Valley Council |
| 1955 | *Joseph W. Taylor | Organ Council |
| 1954 | *Walter B. Norris | Hiram Council |
| 1953 | *Russel G. Bird | Valley Council |
| 1952 | *Chester A. Floyd | Zuni Council |
| 1951 | *Fred B. Hartman | Organ Council |
| Term | Most Illustrious Companion | Past Illustrious Master of |
